Which Is More Secure: Tor vs. I2P vs. Utopia P2P
Maintaining privacy and anonymity online is important for many users. However, we’ve already learned that our data on the internet is of great value to some parties, and there are many ways for them to collect our personal information.
Yet, we have the option of using various services and tools to protect ourselves and prevent information leakage, for instance such popular ones as Tor, I2P, and Utopia P2P (the decentralized ecosystem connected to the Alt-Tech movement.)
Learn more about the Alt-Tech movement here.
In this article, we’ll talk about Tor vs. I2P vs. Utopia P2P. Then, we’ll show you the main differences, advantages, and disadvantages of each tool for a secure internet experience.
Is it possible to remain anonymous on the internet?
Today, many users are looking for a way to improve privacy and browse the web anonymously. This is because they do not want to share their data with outsiders and do not want to be constantly monitored by an internet provider, by developers, and even by government agencies.
Internet anonymity can prevent the collection of personal data by third parties, for example, for inclusion in spam campaigns or targeted advertising.
Read more about internet anonymity here.
Among the options for improving privacy, we can name the use of Tor, I2P, and Utopia P2P. These are services that allow you greater anonymity, although each has its own advantages and differences compared to the other.
Of course, each of them will help you in maintaining anonymity on the web. They will allow you to view the web in a more confidential mode without revealing your data. These are very useful options when we want to prevent our data from being captured. By the way, some of them provide users access to access the Dark Web.
Compare Dark net with Deep Web here.
Utopia P2P’s advantages
Utopia P2P is a unique, third generation decentralized ecosystem that ensures the anonymity and privacy of each user. It is the ecosystem of the future that is available right now. It solves all privacy protection problems of users on the internet.
Furthermore, it is built on a peer-to-peer architecture. The ecosystem’s network is an association of computers based solely on the equality of all participants. Therefore, the more devices involved in data transmission in the ecosystem, the faster and safer it works.
To start, a user just needs to download the ecosystem on their computer and install it. After that, the registration and use of the ecosystem are free and anonymous. You don’t need to enter personal data like your real name, e-mail, phone number, etc. The only thing you need to do is create a nickname and a strong password. Then the ecosystem generates a unique key that opens access to Utopia’s tools. The ecosystem is available for Windows, Linux, and iOS. Soon, the developers plan to release the mobile version of Utopia P2P.
So, Utopia is a platform that does not store users’ data and does not track users’ internet activity. Furthermore, it does not restrict Utopia participant’s freedom of speech and expression, so there is no censorship.
It combines separate tools for messaging, browsing, and even mining in one incredibly user-friendly product. In addition, you can send confidential documents using the built-in email. All messages are encrypted and stored on individual user servers. A user’s online activity in the ecosystem takes place in incognito mode and without tracking of IP addresses. You can create anonymous sites within Utopia, and all visitors and readers of the site will also be anonymous.
The significant benefits of Utopia:
- Peer-to-peer ecosystem. It means that all nodes connected to the network are equal. A P2P network is an entirely decentralized system without any central servers.
- Anonymous ecosystem. No one needs to pass registration by adding a real name, address, or phone number. Everything happens anonymously.
- Multifunctional tools. The ecosystem provides a fully-fledged arsenal of tools for secure and private messaging, file sharing, browsing, gaming, payments, mining, etc.
- No censorship and surveillance. The platform is absolutely free from censorship, surveillance, tracking, or data leaks.
- Anonymous web resource. There is an anonymous web browser that doesn’t collect users’ data. Using it, everyone can host a private website or mirror an existing one within the ecosystem.
Read more about Utopia P2P here.
Tor (The Onion Router) is a network designed and used to ensure anonymity on the internet by passing all traffic through two-way tunnels. It is built between several (mostly three) constantly changing network members, the general list of which (except for “bridges” serving to circumvent censorship) is publicly available.
Each network member has access only to the information necessary to deliver a message to the next network member, so none of them knows both the user’s IP address and the server’s IP address. The rest of the data is encrypted.
A certain disadvantage of the network is that the last link in the chain has access to all the information transmitted to the desired server.
The main user applications of this network are:
- Anonymous surfing of the World Wide Web.
- The use of standard network services like e-mail and IRC located in the WWW.
- Access to hidden .onion sites.
The significant benefits of Tor:
- More active users. Tor is a much more popular service, so it has more active users. It means that there is a lot of data on the operation of the network.
- It blocks DoS attacks better. Tor is bigger and heavier, it has also developed better optimization for blocking and preventing DoS attacks.
Read about the real danger of DoS attacks here.
- Client nodes use little bandwidth. If bandwidth is a problem for users, it should be noted that client nodes do not require much.
- More efficient. Another advantage is that it is more efficient in terms of memory usage.
- More output nodes. Tor is designed to optimize output traffic by having more nodes available.
Learn more about Tor here.
I2P (Invisible Internet Project) is an open-source project that aims to create an anonymous network. The connection in the I2P network is encrypted to protect against intruders and hackers. The I2P network is built using Java on similar principles to Tor.
The many applications on the I2P network include mail, website hosting, IRC chat, collaborative file sharing (ED2K, Gnutella, and BitTorrent), and messengers that use the I2P interface for anonymous communication. In addition, I2P has its internal network database, which is used for the secure distribution of contact information and routing.
I2P users connect using peer-to-peer encrypted tunnels, but there are some technical differences. Unlike Tor, I2P tunnels are unidirectional, so incoming traffic and outgoing traffic are completely separate. Such a measure improves anonymity.
The I2P network is designed to protect communications from Internet service providers that can track user activity on a regular network. It is worth noting that no network can be completely anonymous. Anonymity on the I2P network will increase proportionally as users and network size increase.
I2P is available on desktop computers and smartphones with the Android operating system and embedded systems such as Raspberry Pi.
The significant benefits of I2P:
- Short-lived tunnels. One of the advantages is that I2P tunnels have a short service life. This reduces the number of samples that an attacker can use to attack.
- Great compatibility. Another important advantage of using I2P is that it is more compatible with various activities performed on the internet and the tools that are used in these cases.
- Multiple packets or messages are sent. Unlike Tor, where only one message is sent, multiple packets or messages are sent via I2P and pass through different nodes.
- One-way tunnels. All request and response go different ways.
- Greater personalization. I2P also offers users greater personalization.
Conclusion: Tor vs. I2P vs. Utopia P2P
Finally, if you want to remain anonymous during the entire internet session, encrypt the process of transmitting any data, hide from surveillance, censorship, and ads, and enjoy the benefits of a closed internet space, then choose Utopia.